Anniversary Jewelry Gift Guide: Timeless Ideas from Everglow Jewelry

Whether it’s your first anniversary or your fiftieth, a meaningful piece of jewelry is a classic way to celebrate your love story. At Everglow Jewelry in Tampa, we specialize in helping you choose the perfect anniversary gift—whether you're marking a milestone or just want to say “I still do.”

This guide covers traditional anniversary jewelry by year, modern interpretations, and trending gift ideas that our customers in the Tampa Bay area are loving right now.

Why Jewelry Makes the Perfect Anniversary Gift

Jewelry is wearable, lasting, and personal—everything you want in an anniversary gift. Whether you're adding to their collection or surprising them with their very first piece, a beautiful ring, necklace, bracelet, or earrings will always remind them of your special day.

Plus, with custom design, engraving, and on-site jewelry repair, Everglow Jewelry can help you create or update a piece that’s truly one-of-a-kind.

Milestone Anniversaries and Their Traditional Jewelry

Here’s a breakdown of traditional and modern anniversary jewelry by year, and what it symbolizes:

1st Anniversary – Gold

  • Gift Idea: A dainty gold chain, bracelet, or stackable ring. Gold-filled permanent jewelry is also a trendy and affordable option.

5th Anniversary – Sapphire

  • Gift Idea: Sapphire studs or a silver band with lab-created sapphires for a pop of deep blue elegance.

10th Anniversary – Diamond

  • Gift Idea: Diamond eternity band, diamond pendant, or a lab-grown diamond upgrade for her original engagement ring.

15th Anniversary – Ruby

  • Gift Idea: Ruby necklace or ring to represent passion and enduring love. Available in natural or lab-created stones.

20th Anniversary – Emerald

  • Gift Idea: A custom emerald and diamond pendant or bracelet that brings together elegance and sentiment.

25th Anniversary – Silver

  • Gift Idea: Sterling silver bangles, custom name necklaces, or a silver wedding band upgrade with engraving.

30th Anniversary – Pearl

  • Gift Idea: Classic white pearl studs or a modern take like black or pink freshwater pearl jewelry.

40th Anniversary – Ruby (again)

  • Gift Idea: A ruby cocktail ring or halo earrings to commemorate four decades together.

50th Anniversary – Gold (again)

  • Gift Idea: Solid yellow gold pieces—like a wide “cigar band” style ring, a statement gold bracelet, or matching his-and-hers bands.

Trending Anniversary Jewelry Ideas in Tampa

Our Tampa customers are loving these personalized, meaningful gifts:

  • Engraved bar necklaces with wedding dates or initials

  • Birthstone jewelry featuring the month you were married or your children’s birthdays

  • Permanent jewelry—a symbolic and beautiful option for couples or families

  • Heirloom redesigns, where we update or reset an older ring into a modern piece

  • Stacking anniversary bands to wear alongside an engagement ring or wedding band

Looking to repurpose a sentimental piece? Everglow Jewelry offers custom jewelry design and heirloom remodeling so you can transform something old into something new.

Custom Anniversary Jewelry at Everglow Jewelry

Every relationship is unique—your jewelry should be too. We offer custom anniversary jewelry design right here in our Tampa Palms store. You'll work directly with our design team to create a piece that reflects your story, your style, and your budget.

We also offer:

  • On-site engraving

  • Lab-grown and natural stones

  • Gold, silver, platinum, and mixed-metal options

  • Jewelry appraisals and repairs, including restoration of vintage pieces

Make This Anniversary Unforgettable

Whether you're celebrating your first year together or a lifetime of memories, Everglow Jewelry has the perfect gift to mark the moment. Our team is here to help you find (or create) something they’ll treasure forever.

📍 Visit us in Tampa Palms or contact us to start designing your anniversary gift today.

Because love deserves to sparkle—year after year.

Next
Next

Custom Wedding Bands That Tell Your Story – Made at Everglow Jewelry